Saturday, May 30, 2009

Dispatch from Istanbul - An Interview with Allen Collinsworth

By Andrea McMahan
June 3, 2009

ISTANBUL - I sat down to talk with Allen Collinsworth, an American expat living in Istanbul, about his experiences in Turkey and his perspectives on how the Middle East can strengthen its relations with the west. A former director and fellow at the EastWest Institute in New York, Allen has spent the last eight years living in Istanbul helping to bridge east and west through financial and social entrepreneurship.



Most recently, Allen spent eight months in Iraq as a US defense contractor running one of the largest reconstuction projects in Anbar Province. His experience helping the private sector better understand the local climate and forge meaningful aliances in the middle east makes Allen a valuable source of information.

...read more

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Dispatch from Istanbul - An Interview with Yaman Vuran

By Justin McMahan
May 27, 2009

ISTANBUL - Yaman Vuran is the owner of Lavie Cafe, a lively bistro in Istanbul's trendy Tesvikiye Nisantasi neighborhood - resembling, in many respects, New York's SOHO district. Having attended college in Florida and started businesses in Miami as well as Istanbul, Yaman has a unique perspective on the challenges facing entrepreneurs in both countries, as well as on some of the things that we can learn from each other.

In addition to being an accomplished entrepreneur, Yaman is also a gifted photographer. We have included a few pictures of his cafe, staff and his beloved Princes Island.

Click on the picture of Yaman to hear my full interview with him.

























...read more

Friday, May 22, 2009

An Introduction to Dispatches

By Andrea McMahan
May 21, 2009

Welcome to our blog! I’m sure many of you have come here curious to learn more about our daring and offbeat journey to the Middle East. To those who think we’ve lost out marbles, let me assure you it’s quite the opposite. The Middle East is an awe-inspiring place. Its intersection of beauty, history and passion makes it one of the most studied places in the world. Yet it is also a region filled with contradictions and nuance. Nations continue to vye for justice and purpose even if it comes with a heavy price, while the cultures across the region remain untapped and yet are constantly evolving.

So why the Middle East and why now? To be honest, we feel there’s no better time to visit these countries. President Obama’s popularity can be felt in every corner of the world and has transformed America’s perception abroad. What better time to visit this region than now, under the halo of hope and the potential for renewed acceptance. It is also an ideal time to visit because many of the countries are at an exciting political juncture: both Lebanon and Iran will hold national elections in early June. While we remain unsure if either of these events will unlock sweeping ideological reform, it will be interesting to see if the overtures of the West make an impact on the region’s political ambitions and potentially influence the diplomatic policies of the Middle East in the years ahead. But most importantly, we are anxious to learn whether the differences between our countries will overshadow the strength of our common goals.

We hope you find our forthcoming experiences entertaining and mildly educational. We’ll try and update this site as often as possible and in accordance with the visiting country’s policies. Whatever your reason for visiting our blog—whether you’re looking for an on-the-ground political perspective, insight into the contrasting cultures, or just to see if Justin and Andrea are still alive, we thank you for reading and hope you will stay tuned!

Salam aleikum,

Justin and Andrea
...read more

The View from Istanbul - Day One

By Justin McMahan
May 22, 2009

ISTANBUL - Dre and I launched this blog as a forum in which to write and post audio / video during the six weeks that we will spend in the Middle East. During the next forty plus days, we have reservations / plans to fly / drive to visit with friends in Turkey, Lebanon, Syria, Iran and Egypt. That is the framework. Beyond that, we’ll play it by ear.

Of course we will visit our fair share of mosques, souqs and ruins, but the driving force behind this trip is a desire to learn from and about people from diverse ethnic backgrounds (Turkmen, Arabs, Persians, Kurds), religions (Judaism, Christianity and Islam), sects (Maronite, Sunni, Allawi, Shia) and so forth.


It should be an interesting time to be in the region. Iraq’s neighbors watch nervously as the U.S. draw-down continues apace. Though forced at gunpoint, and in the wake of more than 4,000 American and up to 100,000 Iraqi casualties, the inescapable fact is that a serious effort is underway to build a democracy in the heart of the Levant.

The roots of Iraqi civil society grow stronger by the day. Indeed, while we witness the demise of the San Francisco Chronicle and the Boston Globe, Baghdad is today home to roughly 100 functioning newspapers. Journalists there have no qualms about criticizing the al-Malaki government, or anyone else.

Elections are scheduled for early 2010. In the interim, will the al-Malaki government be able to maintain order but also govern with an even hand and reach out to Sunnis and Kurds? The fate of the Dawa party hangs in the balance. Countries like Egypt, which are grappling these very days with civil society and electoral reform, will watch closely.

We will be in Beirut during the June 7 election. If Hezbollah wins additional seats in parliament, as expected, U.S. and EU governments will be faced with a tough decision. Do they choose not to recognize another democratically elected Islamic party, as they did with Hamas after the January 2006 election, or do they agree on a framework similar to the way they dealt with the IRA’s Sinn Fein, and recognize Hezbollah’s political arm?

We will be in Iran during the June 12 election (also Justine and Stephen’s wedding… congratulations!). The world will watch closely to see if the Iranian people will vote to unclench their government’s fist by voting for the reformer Moussavi. Incidentally, I heard today that Moussavi’s wife is campaigning with and for him and taking on a very public advocacy role. This is a new development in Iranian political campaign gender dynamics.

Meanwhile, President Ahmadinejad, whose political fortunes have been damaged by the drop in oil prices, has campaigned tirelessly these past weeks in a bid to secure the support of his people for another term. Israel will watch closely as they weigh the pros and cons of a pre-emptive military strike on suspected nuclear facilities there. President Obama is expected to be in Israel during the Iran election, perhaps to personally ensure that they refrain from doing so. But even the election of Moussavi is unlikely to provide Israel with much comfort. He would not stop the nuclear program, at least not in the near term, and not without a generous package of incentives.

All of this against a backdrop of a new American President who gave his first interview to Al Arabiya, who made Mahmoud Abbas among the first leaders called and who told an audience in Ankara that “the West will never be at war with Islam.” Obama has taken a harder line with Israel, as evidenced not only by his recent meeting with PM Netanyahu, but also by remarks made by Biden at AIPAC and Secretary Clinton on repeated occasions. In a few weeks, Obama will deliver a highly anticipated speech in Cairo, still the Pennsylvania Avenue of the Arab street. This time, the Street will look for more than just a change in tone, but it will nonetheless be interesting to see how much the President’s remarks resonate in the region and at the polls.
...read more

Tuesday, March 31, 2009

Say No to the F-22

By Justin McMahan
April 1, 2009


WASHINGTON – In the coming days, President Obama must decide whether to approve the request of Air Force chief of staff General Norton Schwartz for more F-22 Raptors. The request is in addition to the 183 F-22s – each costing some $138 million, or $361 million, if you include overall program costs – that Congress approved in 2006.

Lockheed Martin, which builds the F-22, as well as Boeing and Pratt & Whitney, frequently take out full page ads in The Hill and other publications read by lawmakers and their staff imploring Congress to continue to fund the program, For National Security. For Economic Stability. For the over 300 million Americans it keeps safe – and the more than 95,000 Americans who are employed directly and indirectly.

Not all members of the Defense establishment agree, however, that additional F-22s are needed to keep American safe. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, for one, has expressed concern that procuring more F-22s would come at the expense of the more affordable F-35 Joint Strike Fighter.

From an economic standpoint, Gates’ position is important because the production of the F-35, which may be sold overseas, has the potential to generate sorely needed revenue. The F-22, meanwhile, has been banned for sale to foreign governments by House Appropriations Chairman David Obey (D-WI).

Considerable debate exists within the Defense establishment concerning the utility of investing tens of billions of dollars in next generation aircraft at a time when more robust counterinsurgency capabilities are needed to tamp down growing unrest in Afghanistan, Iraq and, possibly, Pakistan. Secretary Gates is adamant that the killing of Afghan and Pakistani civilians by errant bombs and missile attacks hinders our ability to win hearts and minds there.

Indeed, a central lesson from the early years of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars is that counterinsurgency is less about killing insurgents and more about devising political solutions to local problems while being shot at. Solving problems at the community level and building long-term, genuine partnerships with the local population is the best way to diminish insurgents’ influence. F-22s Raptors do not help to build these partnerships.

If President-elect Obama is serious about placing a renewed emphasis on nation building, as his statements concerning Afghanistan and Pakistan attest, he needs to work with Congress to ensure that already strained Defense budgets are not saddled with unnecessary appropriations for next generation fighter jets that do not help our effort there.

The F-22 Raptor program alone has cost American taxpayers $62 billion, almost twice the entire 2008 State Department budget of $35 billion, which is less than 8% of the $481 billion Defense Department budget (less than 6% if we include $162 billion in supplemental war funding). If we are serious about defeating insurgencies in South Asia, we need to shift resources away from nice-to-have next generation defense programs and instead fund the additional nation building responsibilities that we assumed when President Obama dispatched more than 17,000 additional U.S. troops to Afghanistan.

While it is understandable that some members of Congress, whose constituents include employees of Lockheed and other companies that build the F-22, advocate additional funding for the program, sound fiscal judgment and the need to win the wars in South Asia and Iraq make a strong case – if not for additional State Department funding - at least for postponing procurement of additional F-22s.

To preserve jobs, funds earmarked for the F-22 could still be allocated to Lockheed, but only to produce systems that will make us safer, like Lockheed’s Maritime Integrated Domain Awareness System (MIDAS). By allocating more money to MIDAS, President Obama would take an important step toward securing our nation’s ports and lessening the chance that terrorists will detonate a nuclear weapon in the port of Oakland, Long Beach or New Jersey.

President Obama talks tough about the importance of writing reality-based budgets and making sure that we have the money to cover expenditures. If that is not the case, he says, we need to make some hard budget choices. This is one of the easy ones. President Obama should say “No” to procuring additional F-22s.

Justin McMahan, a former Director at the EastWest Institute, is enrolled in Georgetown’s School of Foreign Service and MBA joint degree program.
...read more